Murders by Melissa

Murders by Melissa · Custom Mystery Entertainment

Murder Mystery Parties in NYC & Northern New Jersey

Writing and performing thrilling, interactive murder mystery shows! Serving New York City, Manhattan, and Northern New Jersey, including Bergen, Passaic, Essex, Hudson, Union, and Morris counties.

Custom scripts • Live actors • Interactive mysteries • Recommended for 20–100 guests

An unforgettable whodunit

Our Shows

Murders by Melissa creates interactive, custom murder mystery experiences that immerse your guests in a night of suspense, laughter, and unforgettable surprises. Ideal for private parties, corporate team-building, fundraisers, and community events.

We collaborate with you to tailor the story, choose characters, and craft a show that matches your audience and venue. Pick a victim, invite your guests, and let us handle the mystery — from scripts to actors to props.

Recommended audience size: 20–100 guests. We bring interactive murder mystery entertainment directly to your venue throughout Manhattan, New York City, and Northern New Jersey. Whether you're planning a corporate team-building event in NYC, a private murder mystery party in Manhattan, or a fundraiser in Bergen County, we'll create an unforgettable experience for your guests.

Private Parties

Turn your birthday, anniversary, or special occasion into a night of secrets, suspects, and laughter.

Corporate Events

Bring the team together for a custom mystery at your holiday party or workplace celebration. Explore corporate events.

Fundraisers & Community Events

Give guests an entertaining reason to gather in support of a great cause or local organization.

Company parties with a deadly twist

Make Your Next Corporate Event a Killer One!

Looking for corporate party entertainment that's more memorable than another dinner or team-building exercise? Murders by Melissa creates custom, interactive murder mystery events for company holiday parties, team bonding, and retirement celebrations. Serving New York City, Manhattan, and Northern New Jersey, we bring the actors, costumes, props, and plot twists to your venue for an experience your whole team will be talking about.

Explore Corporate Murder Mystery Events
Your team.
Your mystery.

Holiday parties · Team building · Retirements

A few suspiciously good stories

Past Shows

From speakeasies to trading floors, every mystery has its own cast of unforgettable characters. Here are some of the original murder mystery themes we've performed.

The roaring twenties

Speakeasy

When the proprietor of a local pub throws a party to celebrate his new brew, a host of interesting characters arrive. A 1920s speakeasy themed mystery unfolds!

Wall Street, 1980s

1980s Finance Firm

Greed is good, but murder is better! When the CEO of a family-owned financial firm abruptly retires, he leaves his empire to his foolish son, snubbing both his brilliant daughter and his star trader. In a world of big money, bigger egos, and questionable decisions, someone's about to make a killing!

Celebrity scandal

Musical Fraud Exposed?

A famous internet star agrees to do an in-person event for the first time - but cannot survive his own performance.

Campaign calamity

Political Mystery

When a local politician decides to run for President, the people are ready to listen. His campaign is cut short when he gets a shocking surprise as he starts his speech!

A secret society

The Mysterious Lodge

A thrilling show set in a Masonic lodge where a new initiation takes a dark turn.

Raffles & rivalry

PTA Tricky-Tray Travesty

Just when you think you've attended the worst tricky tray due to the horrible prizes, it gets even worse when the PTA president is murdered!

Wedding day disaster

'Till Death do us Part...

A wedding reception turns deadly when the groom is murdered. Did the bride get cold feet? Was it the worst man? The parents of the bride?

Literary intrigue

Author Signing

Everyone is excited when an author comes out of retirement to write one more book and do an exclusive signing event. Excitement turns to horror when author shows up dead! Unravel the mystery of her retirement and return.

Early American drama

A Revolution to Remember

The late 1700s were a bustling time for the newly formed United States. While democracy was a given, not everyone was in agreement as to what the future of our towns would look like. Attend the first council meeting of a newly formed town as a Representative from the Continental Congress, a local business leader, and several other characters duke it out to decide the towns fate. But, is it worth dying for?

Yours can be next!

Your adventure awaits! Fill out our interest form to find out more.

Tell Us About Your Event

Don't just take our word for it

Testimonials

“These murder mysteries are fun, engaging, and community participation is very high. They have been an excellent fundraiser for the Friends of the Maurice M Pine Library. We recently held a murder mystery for the Bergen County Cooperative Library System's annual scholarship fundraiser and a great time was had by all. Highly recommended.”

— Adele P.

“Everyone had a blast, the actors were hilarious but also believable and not over the top.”

— Debra M.

“I've never had so much fun being murdered! They wrote a mystery custom for our lodge that had adults and kids excited. We can't wait to have them back!”

— Roy S.

“Everyone truly had the best, most memorable time. The response from everyone was through the roof.

Thanks for bringing such fun and commitment, and Nick & Melissa, thank you especially for writing such a perfectly tailored, delightful caper. We're so grateful!”

— KP from Pulley

Extra! Extra!

In the Press

Bergen County Library Story (Yahoo News)

Murders by Melissa has been featured in local coverage. An article covering a murder mystery event hosted at a Bergen County library highlights the community impact and fundraising success.

Read the article on Yahoo News

The usual suspects

Murder Mystery Party FAQs

Can you customize a murder mystery for our event?

Yes. We work with you to tailor the story, characters, and show to your audience and venue, providing a custom murder mystery experience rather than an off-the-shelf game.

How many guests can attend a show?

Our recommended audience size is 20–100 guests. Tell us about your event in the interest form so we can discuss your needs.

Where do you perform murder mysteries?

We bring interactive murder mystery shows to you! We can accommodate venues in New York City, Manhattan, and Northern New Jersey, including Bergen, Passaic, Essex, Hudson, Union, and Morris counties.

What does Murders by Melissa provide?

We provide the actors, costumes, props, and script for your murder mystery event.

Your guests. Our mystery. One unforgettable night.

Contact Us — Let's Plan Something to Die For!

For bookings or inquiries, please fill out our interest form. Tell us about your date, venue, and guests, and we'll get back to you about bringing a customized murder mystery to your event.

Book an Event / Interest Form

Private parties · Corporate celebrations · Fundraisers · Community events